Challengers of the law said the testimonies exemplified how just a few of many Pennsylvanians would struggle to gather the documents required — including a birth certificate — to obtain a valid photo ID, and they would be unable to endure the extra trip to a state licensing center. They should have proposed an ID law that would have taken effect in She estimated at leastregistered voters lack proper ID, based on a statistical analysis of voting records. So, the new ID system is a red-herring. They also said absentee-ballot rules in Pennsylvania are stricter than Judge Simpson implied. The alarmism of the left on this continues to be laughable. Moreover, state officials acknowledge that it was not until Tuesday, a full two weeks after the court opinion, that the last of the pre-decision billboards announcing photo ID as a requirement came down. Instead they seem to think their voters are not capable of getting IDs ever. Obama, who won Pennsylvania inhas been pulling consistently ahead of Mr.
Judge clears the way for voters to be required to have photo ID; Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson said those challenging the law.
Robert Simpson Ballotpedia
Judge Simpson ruled this morning to deny the injunction to prevent the Voter ID law from going into effect for this November's elections. Pennsylvania's most. Pennsylvania voter ID law Judge Robert Simpson View full sizeExpress-Times File PhotoCommonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson, left.
It was not enforced in the November election, but its long-term prospects remain in question. Simpson did not see it that way. Good point, Ryan. It was already a political lightning rod when a top state Republican lawmaker boasted to a GOP dinner in June that the ID requirement "is going to allow Gov.
So if the courts had permitted the law to go forward, perhaps three quarters of a million registered Pennsylvania voters would have been unable to vote this November.
In smaller type, it says photo ID is not mandatory. Feb 8
Pennsylvania Judge Keeps Voter ID Law Intact on Its Way to Higher In his ruling on Wednesday, Judge Robert Simpson of Pennsylvania. Strict voter ID laws remain in Kansas, Indiana, Georgia and Tennessee, The Pennsylvania judge who ruled on Tuesday, Robert Simpson of.
David… quit whining.
She said the court could hear arguments and announce its decision within a month. Their lawyers said it was disturbing that Judge Simpson did not recognize the constitutional right to vote as sufficiently fundamental, especially because the state acknowledged that it had no evidence of voter fraud at polling stations.
A tie vote at the Pennsylvania Supreme Court would allow the law to go into effect.
Judge Robert Simpson ruling on Pennsylvania's voter identification law WHYY
As a result, the state has been virtually empty of presidential TV ads and off the candidates' beaten paths to more contested states in recent weeks. However, Simpson based his decision on guidelines given to him days ago by the high court justices, and it could easily be the final word on the law just five weeks before the Nov.
Full Article: Pa.
He will decide by mid-August. In a page decision, Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson said he would Republican-backed voter ID laws have become a hot button issue in many. Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson has ruled that Pennsylvanians will not need a photo ID to vote in the Nov. 6 election.
[EL] Judge Simpson's Injunction and HAVA
That court currently consists of three Republicans and three Democrats. Good point, Ryan. It was and Rehnquist, a practicing lawyer at the time, demanded to see identification and conversed with Hispanics to determine if they spoke sufficient English to vote.
Simpson did not see it that way. That investigation continues.
Pennsylvania Judge Refuses to Halt Voter ID Law The Pew Charitable Trusts
CARTA AOS CORINTIOS CID MOREIRA BIBLIA
|And, yes, there are many people, especially senior women, who would have difficulty meeting the restrictive ID requirements, despite ample other forms of ID that the state is disallowing.
The law itself has not cleared the constitutional challenges before it, and indications from the state Supreme Court are that the law still faces significant legal problems.
In Ohio, a dispute over rules for early voting ended on Wednesday when the secretary of state set uniform hours statewide. But Democrats have used their opposition to the law as a rallying cry, turning it into a valuable tool to motivate volunteers and campaign contributions while other opponents of the law, including labor unions, good government groups, the NAACP, AARP and the League of Women Voters, hold voter education drives and protest rallies.
So, the new ID system is a red-herring. Pennsylvania voters will not be required to show photo identification in the primary election, but some worry that voters may still be confused.